Quantcast
A Way with Words, public radio's lively language call-in show, hosted by Martha Barnette and Grant Barrett.
Listen | Newsletter | Ask a Question | Donate Now | Sponsorship |Discussion Forums
Discussion Forums | Start a New Discussion
 
You must be logged in to post Login Register
Search Forums:


 






Minimum search word length is 4 characters – Maximum search word length is 84 characters
Wildcard Usage:
*  matches any number of characters    %  matches exactly one character

 

A Way with Words is supported by:

 

10 Years in the Making with 10,000 New Words and Senses.   National University: Change your future today.

Watershed

UserPost

9:08PM
Mar-23-09


dmonfils

New Member

posts 2

The explanation for watershed led me to think literally of water being parted. I kept waiting for the answer to lead somewhere biblical and specifically Moses parting the Red Sea. Being that watershed moments are historically monumental, I assumed this was where the discussion would lead, yet it didn't. Too far of a reach?

8:02AM
Mar-24-09


Grant Barrett

San Diego, California

Admin

posts 1197

Yeah, too far to reach. Still, an evocative image!

2:52PM
Mar-24-09


martha

martha

Admin

posts 817

Funny how very many different images this term conjures, isn't it? And none correct!

2:52PM
Mar-24-09


martha

martha

Admin

posts 817

Funny how very many different images this term conjures, isn't it? And none correct!

4:57PM
Mar-24-09


EmmettRedd

Admin

posts 363

Post edited 10:05PM – Mar-24-09 by EmmettRedd


I just listened to your “watershed” episode and disagree with your explanation. (I’ll admit the OED gives your explanation as its first definition, but I think that current (engineering/technical) usage is more along the lines of the second definition, as I explain below.)

The ridge line you describe is more properly called a “divide” as in “Continental Divide.” The watershed is all the land that drains (or sheds) water into a particular river or basin. The Continental Divide separates the Missouri River watershed from the Snake River watershed and the Great Basin, much of which is the Great Salt Lake watershed.

I live in the Hominy Creek (an 1860’s map at the Missouri Geological Survey says Harmony Creek) watershed which is part of the Pomme de Terre watershed, part of the Osage River watershed, part of the Missouri River watershed, and, finally, part of the Mississippi River watershed. My 5-mile-away farm is on the other side of a divide that stretches about 30 miles from Indian Point at the Pomme de Terre lake. It is in the Brush Creek watershed, part of the Lindley Creek watershed, part of the Pomme de Terre watershed, etc.

I think the “watershed moment in history” has the connotation of an unstoppable collection of events which will result in a great change. So too is a flood in a watershed. The people of Fargo are sandbagging their town against the Red River because there is an unstoppable collection of snow and heavy rain (none of which causing a flood on its own) in its watershed. Their sandbagging is a great change for their city trying to avoid a greater change which would result if the flooding cannot be contained.

Emmett

P.S. What? No math?