Arguably | Open House, Open Mouth, Open Call | Discussion Forum | A Way with Words
Latest News: Texas tunes in! KERA 90.1 in Dallas/Fort Worth and KOCV 91.3 in Odessa now air the program. (more news)
A Way with Words, public radio's lively language call-in show, hosted by Martha Barnette and Grant Barrett.
Listen | Get the Newsletter | Ask a Question | Donate | Discussion Forums
Discussion Forums | Start a New Discussion
Current User: Guest Login Register
Please consider registering

Search 
Search Forums:


 




UserPost

7:50AM
Dec-05-07


maven

Member

posts 3

I am so tired of hearing the word “arguably” in newscasts (particularly NPR). Just what does it mean, and is there an easier way to express the fact that this information may not be true?

1:53PM
Mar-06-08


Wordsmith

Member

posts 158

“Arguably” ? (that is, more or less =) ‘what can be argued for, with near certainty’, as in, “Citizen Kane is arguably the greatest film ever.” This can (and has) been argued for by many people. But notice the argument element here. There is always the possibility of argument against. As by those who think that “Gone with the Wind” was the greatest film ever. But then define “greatest.” I use the asymptotic symbol [?] because, “arguably” can also mean “moot”. This sense is normally found with its adjectival form, “arguable” and doesn’t seem to be all that common nowadays.
But, however “arguably” is used, it should never, ever be used with factual data which is indisputable, that is, cannot be argued for or against by anyone, as in, “Jupiter is *arguably the largest planet in our solar system,” since it need not (and cannot) be argued.
There are other ways of expressing “arguably.” But many of these border on weasel words; e.g., “Almost everyone likes X,”, “When people hear X, they think of the best,” “Brand X wins, hands down,” “There is nothing {superlative} than X (or a nice, {adjective} X),” etc. Another popular way of saying “arguably” is “quite possibly”, as in, “X is quite possibly the greatest rapper of all time.” The longwinded version of “arguably” is “It can be argued (with near certainty) that…”
It does tire on the ears, the word “arguably”, as do all of its journalese kith and kin. When in doubt, say what you mean. “I like X more than Y” is perfectly fine (and less sneaky-sounding).

Reply to Post


Reply to Topic: Arguably
Courtesy matters! All posts and comments are moderated and subject to approval.

NOTE: New Posts are subject to administrator approval before being displayed

Guest Name (Required):

Guest EMail (Required):

Topic Reply:

HTML Editor
Save New PostSmileysOptions

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
1 + 3
   

 
Confused Cool Cry Embarassed Frown Kiss Laugh Smile Surprised Wink Yell

Search