Quantcast
Latest News: Texas tunes in! KERA 90.1 in Dallas/Fort Worth and KOCV 91.3 in Odessa now air the program. (more news)
A Way with Words, public radio's lively language call-in show, hosted by Martha Barnette and Grant Barrett.
Listen | Get the Newsletter | Ask a Question | Donate | Discussion Forums
Discussion Forums | Start a New Discussion
Current User: Guest Login Register
Please consider registering

Search 
Search Forums:


 




Do I hate it when people ask a question and then answer it? Yes.

Add a New Topic Reply to Post
UserPost

9:37AM
Feb-28-08


Rob

Guest

Do I think this construction is pretentious and unnecessary? Absolutely. Do I hope Martha and Grant can help explain it? Yes. Do I really think it’ll go away soon? No.

I hear that all over the place, in casual conversation as well as in the media. Pundits use it all the time. Donald Rumsfeld became famous for interviewing himself.

For example. You might hear on a Sunday morning news show, “Does Obama have momentum? Yes. Can Clinton catch up? I think she can.”

Why not just say, “Obama has momentum, but Clinton can catch up.” So much cleaner!

So the question is … am I weird to let this bother me so much? Also, when and how and for heaven’s sake WHY did this start? It seems to me it was around sort of the mid-90s, particularly in corporate-speak settings.

Can anyone here help me? I think so.

8:41PM
Mar-05-08


Wordsmith

Member

posts 158

I think the purpose of this technique (if you can call it that) is to express to the listener/viewer that you (the speaker) know that this question may be aimed at your discussion/speech/lecture/etc. and you want to save time by answering it before it is asked. But you can see how presumptious people can get with this: “Would I accept a hundred dollar bill from you? Absolutely!” I think effective speaking cuts two ways: a) people need to orate more dynamically and emotively, but b) even Max Headroom could orate more dynamically and emotively if he were so programmed. My point is, they (sc. rhetorical questions answered by the one who proposed it) should be used sparingly. But, where does one draw the line?? Honestly, I can’t answer thatquestion.

[NB—When using a question the asker is going to answer, I find it less confusing if the question ends in two question marks. One for the sentence being interrogative and the other for the question being interrogative; i.e., “are you asking this question”?]

Reply to Post


Reply to Topic: Do I hate it when people ask a question and then answer it? Yes.
Courtesy matters! All posts and comments are moderated and subject to approval.

NOTE: New Posts are subject to administrator approval before being displayed

Guest Name (Required):

Guest EMail (Required):

Topic Reply:

HTML Editor
Save New PostSmileysOptions

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of:
10 + 12
   

 
Confused Cool Cry Embarassed Frown Kiss Laugh Smile Surprised Wink Yell

Search