Quantcast
A Way with Words, public radio's lively language call-in show, hosted by Martha Barnette and Grant Barrett.
Listen | Get the Newsletter | Ask a Question | Discussion Forum
Current User: Guest Login Register
Please consider registering

Search 
Search Forums:


 




In orbit or on orbit?

Add a New Topic Reply to Post
UserPost

8:55AM
Aug-27-08


BC12D

posts 1

Whenever I watch a space shuttle launch, I notice that the NASA commentators use the phrase, “on orbit” when the shuttle has made it to space. However, most news outlets use, “in orbit” to describe the shuttle’s location.

Which is correct?

9:28AM
Aug-27-08


dilettante

posts 113

Both, perhaps?

Here’s a link to usage in a recent novel: Orbit, by John J. Nance.

Google hits for “on orbit” appear to skew heavily to pages related to NASA and space.

2:18PM
Sep-03-08


Dan Heim

Guest

You know, I noticed that terminology starting up some time ago … maybe 5-10 years. I don’t like “on orbit.” I agree that an astronaut is “in orbit.” Funny thing is how this migrated to other areas as well. I hear weather people say things like “12 inches of rain on the year” and sportscasters say “150 yards on the half.” Strange how the language can morph like, sometimes for no apparent good reason (like in this case).

Jeeeez … another math test. I gotta figure out how to register here.

1:47PM
Sep-05-08


martha

Moderator

martha

posts 453

Thanks for pointing this out, BC12D. I’d missed that particular phrase. Wonder if NASA has a specific technical reason for saying it that way?

I’m with Dan — “in orbit” sounds better to my ear. (But then, I’m not from New York and if I have to wait for other people to be served first, I much prefer to stand “in line,” not “on line.”

1:49PM
Sep-05-08


martha

Moderator

martha

posts 453

Thanks for pointing this out, BC12D. I’d missed this. Wonder if NASA has some particular technical reason to say it this way?

Add a New Topic Reply to Post


Reply to Topic: In orbit or on orbit?
Courtesy matters! All posts and comments are moderated and subject to approval.

NOTE: New Posts are subject to administrator approval before being displayed

Guest Name (Required):

Guest EMail (Required):

Guest URL (required)

Math Required!
What is the sum of: 10 + 12        (Required)

Topic Reply:


 
© Simple:Press Forum - Version 3.1.4 (Build 357)