If you want to write "my friends' friends," which is best?
(1) My friends' friends
(2) Â Friends of my friends
(3) Â Friends of my friends'
(4) Â Friends of mine's
(5) Â Friends of friends of mine
(1) clumsy, hence the alternatives.
(2) probably most favored, though liable to be confused as the expansive form of 'friends of mine.'
(3) Â not wrong, but a little strange looking.
(4) Â not wrong, another form of (3), but too strange looking.
(5) Â Too long.
A nitpick: I don't think #1 is clumsy, but there's one way in which it differs in meaning from the rest:Â "My friends" means not "some friends of me" but "the friends of me".Â So technically "my friends' friends" means "the friends of my friends".Â #1 really has to be "some of my friends' friends", to be picky about it, and then it does begin to sound clumsy.
(Kudos, by the way, on ruling that #3 is not actually wrong.)
I like 1) or 2) in this case. I am personally confounded with coming up with a rule as to when to use the subjective or the possessive in example 3), but I affirm that in most cases you can use either. I would not understand example 4) to mean "friends of my friends" if I saw it. In fact, it looks to me like a typo of "friends of mine." I don't think you can add a possessive ending to "mine" forming "mine's" -- unless of course you mean "mine" as a source of raw ore. Example 5) seems awkward, but could have a useful nuance of affirming that you know these second-degree friends.
Back on the topic of example 3) refer to the previous thread in which my confusion is quite manifest:
1) Admit we were possessive and that our language has become unmanageable
Some day I will have to do some legitimate research on this topic.
Most Users Ever Online: 1147
Currently Browsing this Page:
Bob Bridges: 676
Ron Draney: 624
Guest Posters: 605
Newest Members: wordwonderer, Abbyabi098, Gilliflower, jodymask, ernestomalley, SnorePhat, vernal, ToddThompson, niamhk, JeremyAxe
Moderators: Grant Barrett (1420)