Home » Discussion Forum

Discussion Forum—A Way with Words, a fun radio show and podcast about language

Discussion Forum (Archived)

Please consider registering
Guest
Forum Scope


Match



Forum Options



Min search length: 3 characters / Max search length: 84 characters
The forums are currently locked and only available for read only access
sp_TopicIcon
Is up on?
Guest
21
2014/04/11 - 12:36am

No, that's not quite correct. If you're at the North Pole, for example, the only direction is south. If the Sun is up, it will still be moving from east to west, thus the shadow on the sundial will move west to east ... CW in that frame of reference.

It doesn't make any difference whether the sundial is horizontal or vertical. Both variations rely on the east-to-west motion of the Sun to record time.

You are correct that, in the southern hemisphere, sundials need to face north (south of 23.5 ° latitude) to consistently cast a shadow to the south. But that shadow will then move CCW in the southern hemisphere frame of reference.

 

 

Robert
553 Posts
(Offline)
22
2014/04/11 - 4:15am

You are right about the exact point at the North Pole. At that point your shadow rotates round at your feet, CW as you look down on the earth.

At near the North Pole, you still have the same phenomenon, except there is still a north-south distinction, so the shadow rotates, like I said before, West-North-East-South-West.

Which way a sun dial should face? The horizontal style has no issue obviously. The vertical kind needs to face where the sun is, or else it just has a black face. In the northern parts, you want it to face south (though not necessarily exactly south). The tip of the rod that tells time, will cast its shadow first in West, moving lower to the bottom toward noon, then ending in East. And when you look at it while facing north (it facing south), that's a CCW rotation.

I don't think I can do much better than that.

deaconB
744 Posts
(Offline)
23
2014/04/11 - 4:18am

Heimhenge said
No, that's not quite correct. If you're at the North Pole, for example, the only direction is south. If the Sun is up, it will still be moving from east to west, thus the shadow on the sundial will move west to east ... CW in that frame of reference.

If the only direction is south, the use of east and west is not just confusing, it's just plain wrong.  

Let's poke a barber pole candy cane at Santa's house as a sundial.. At roughly 12:00 Zulu, the sun will appear to come from the Isle of Wight.   About five hours later, it will appear to come from Lancaster. Pennsylvania.   That is, the sun seems to revolve around the sundial in a clockwise manner and the shadow as well, although out of phase by pi radians.

Poke a skinny penguin in the ice of Antarctica, as another sundial.   At about 05:00 Zulu, the sun will appear in the direction of Quito.   About five hours later, the sun will be coming from the direction of Sydney.   However, as we're on the underside of the Earth, we are looking at the sundial from underneath, which means the sun (and the out-pf-phase shadow) is still moving in a clockwise direction.

You could check it out on a computer, I suppose, but that's a bad idea, as most computers have lost 39 seconds of time since 1970.

 

EmmettRedd
859 Posts
(Offline)
24
2014/04/11 - 6:14am

deaconB said

Heimhenge said
No, that's not quite correct. If you're at the North Pole, for example, the only direction is south. If the Sun is up, it will still be moving from east to west, thus the shadow on the sundial will move west to east ... CW in that frame of reference.

If the only direction is south, the use of east and west is not just confusing, it's just plain wrong.  

Let's poke a barber pole candy cane at Santa's house as a sundial.. At roughly 12:00 Zulu, the sun will appear to come from the Isle of Wight.   About five hours later, it will appear to come from Lancaster. Pennsylvania.   That is, the sun seems to revolve around the sundial in a clockwise manner and the shadow as well, although out of phase by pi radians.

Poke a skinny penguin in the ice of Antarctica, as another sundial.   At about 05:00 Zulu, the sun will appear in the direction of Quito.   About five hours later, the sun will be coming from the direction of Sydney.   However, as we're on the underside of the Earth, we are looking at the sundial from underneath, which means the sun (and the out-pf-phase shadow) is still moving in a clockwise direction.

You could check it out on a computer, I suppose, but that's a bad idea, as most computers have lost 39 seconds of time since 1970.

 

Heimhenge is correct.

Since Quito is on the equator, let's forget Lancaster. To one standing at the north pole, Quito is to the right of the Isle of Wight. To one standing at the south pole, Quito is to the left of the Isle of Wight. 'Righty tighty' is CW; 'Lefty loosie' is CCW.

BTW, the straight edge of the gnomon matches a line from the Southern Cross to Polaris. So gnomons at the Poles are best made by vertical poles.

Guest
25
2014/04/11 - 7:52am

I must have made a typo. I thought I logged into A Way With Words. Clearly I mistyped it as A Way With Worlds.

Guest
26
2014/04/11 - 10:36am

Robert said: Which way a sun dial should face? The horizontal style has no issue obviously. The vertical kind needs to face where the sun is, or else it just has a black face. In the northern parts, you want it to face south (though not necessarily exactly south). The tip of the rod that tells time, will cast its shadow first in West, moving lower to the bottom toward noon, then ending in East. And when you look at it while facing north (it facing south), that's a CCW rotation.

I stand corrected regarding sundials attached to vertical south-facing walls (in the northern hemisphere above latitude 23.5 °). The shadow motion would indeed be CCW in that case. I've never see that type of sundial, but know they are in use. I have a classic horizontal sundial in my front yard. It's properly oriented and reasonably accurate. And since AZ doesn't observe daylight saving time, the sundial needs no seasonal corrections. My sundial has a series of hour-mark lines for different seasons and Sun altitudes - not a single hour-mark line like the cheap garden variety sundials you'd find at, say, Home Depot.

The problem with sundials mounted on vertical south-facing surfaces is that, after the Vernal Equinox, the Sun will set north of due west, and that vertical surface will then be in shade, rendering the sundial useless near sunrise and sunset for half the year. I'm sure they have a decorative architectural niche, but if you're serious about using a sundial, you want the classic horizontal type with multiple hour-mark lines.

Glenn, I think this "War of the Words" is over at this point.   :)

 

Guest
27
2014/04/11 - 6:02pm

Glenn said
I must have made a typo. I thought I logged into A Way With Words. Clearly I mistyped it as A Way With Worlds.

If I ever have occasion to construct a fantasy world it will be a requirement that Gnomon is an island.

Guest
28
2014/04/12 - 2:49pm

Tromboniator said: If I ever have occasion to construct a fantasy world it will be a requirement that Gnomon is an island.

My initial impression was that your clever non sequitur had ended this thread. Then it hit me: Could Gnomon be a peninsula?

[Younger forum members will have a tough time with that one.]

Guest
29
2014/04/13 - 1:02am

"After Bathing at Baxter's"

deaconB
744 Posts
(Offline)
30
2014/04/13 - 3:50am

Heimhenge said

Tromboniator said: If I ever have occasion to construct a fantasy world it will be a requirement that Gnomon is an island.

My initial impression was that your clever non sequitur had ended this thread. Then it hit me: Could Gnomon be a peninsula?

[Younger forum members will have a tough time with that one.]

New Zebedee was on the lower peninsula, but it's us old geezers that are more likely to have trouble with that.

 

Guest
31
2014/04/14 - 3:06pm

Tromboniator said: "After Bathing at Baxter's"

I figured you might be a Airplane fan.

Not a lot of room for trombones in their music, but I can follow along on a few of their songs with my electric bass. I especially like Saturday Afternoon from that album, but much of their music is pretty complex and hard to play (at least for a beginner like me). Man, this thread has really diverged from the original question. Not like this hasn't happened before, but then, that's one of the reasons I love this forum.

But to respond to your comment, I expect that, to be a peninsula, it would largely depend on who you were bathing with. :)

Guest
32
2014/04/15 - 6:07pm

Probably easier to follow Casady's line on a bass guitar than a bass trombone. Musically he casts a long shadow (said he, desperately trying to stay on topic, whatever it was).

deaconB
744 Posts
(Offline)
33
2014/04/17 - 5:18am

tromboniator said
If I ever have occasion to construct a fantasy world it will be a requirement that Gnomon is an island.

"Gnomon is an island entire of itself" - Dinne

EmmettRedd
859 Posts
(Offline)
34
2014/04/17 - 6:02am

deaconB said

tromboniator said
If I ever have occasion to construct a fantasy world it will be a requirement that Gnomon is an island.

"Gnomon is an island entire of itself" - Dinne

Obviously, Gnomon is gno man.

Forum Timezone: America/Los_Angeles
Show Stats
Administrators:
Martha Barnette
Grant Barrett
Moderators:
Grant Barrett
Top Posters:
Newest Members:
Mike Brock
Forum Stats:
Groups: 1
Forums: 1
Topics: 3647
Posts: 18912

 

Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 618
Members: 1266
Moderators: 1
Admins: 2
Most Users Ever Online: 1147
Currently Online:
Guest(s) 41
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)