Home » Discussion Forum

Discussion Forum—A Way with Words, a fun radio show and podcast about language

Discussion Forum (Archived)

Please consider registering
Guest
Forum Scope


Match



Forum Options



Min search length: 3 characters / Max search length: 84 characters
The forums are currently locked and only available for read only access
sp_TopicIcon
Well/good - Miscorrection
Guest
1
2014/09/06 - 4:48am

I don't actually know whether polecats (skunks) smell well, though I imagine they do, since they forage at night. They are certainly known for not smelling good, even at a considerable distance! I don't think there's much value in being a stickler about "well" and "good" in response to "How are you?" where no-one really could mistake the intent, but where the confusion is possible, it seems worth maintaining the distinction.

Robert
553 Posts
(Offline)
2
2014/09/06 - 8:32am

It seems clear enough that by 'distinction' you mean that between the olfactory sensitivity (well), and the odor (good).

But can there be room for  'well' to be for odor, and still be distinct from 'good' ?

Suppose you have aficionados of pressed flowers.  The superficial observer might say that the dried thing still smells good, but the aficionado might sniff up and down just too decide if the thing actually smells well.

Guest
3
2014/09/06 - 2:20pm

Robert said
But can there be room for  'well' to be for odor, and still be distinct from 'good' ?

I don't think so. Well  is an adverb, so it can't modify a noun, odor. You can have a good odor but not a well odor.
deaconB
744 Posts
(Offline)
4
2014/09/12 - 12:25am

I don't think so. Well  is an adverb, so it can't modify a noun, odor. You can have a good odor but not a well odor.

But smell is both a verb and a noun, and that's the word that was used.

I think it's odd that the verb smell means both to detect an odor and to emit an odor, but it provides enough humor to persist.

EmmettRedd
859 Posts
(Offline)
5
2014/09/12 - 6:36am

Well is both an adverb and a noun. The new pump in my well is working well. But, I broke too many things to call the job I did replacing it good.

EmmettRedd
859 Posts
(Offline)
6
2014/09/20 - 6:59pm

I noticed today there is a 4-word sentence which both good and well are grammatically correct:

I have been good. I have been well.

I realize good is a predicate adjective. But, is well an adverb here; is the sentence idiomatic; or is there another explanation?

Guest
7
2014/09/20 - 7:36pm

EmmettRedd said
I noticed today there is a 4-word sentence which both good and well are grammatically correct:

I have been good. I have been well.

I realize good is a predicate adjective. But, is well an adverb here; is the sentence idiomatic; or is there another explanation?

I believe well is also a predicate adjective, they just mean two different things.  Good describes how you're acting and well describes your health.  I have heard that good is beginning to be acceptable for describing health in the sentence, "I am good" but I must resist that movement.  You may say, "I feel good" or "I feel well" and they can be interchangeable but "I am good", meaning health, is out for me.

Forum Timezone: America/Los_Angeles
Show Stats
Administrators:
Martha Barnette
Grant Barrett
Moderators:
Grant Barrett
Top Posters:
Newest Members:
Mike Brock
Forum Stats:
Groups: 1
Forums: 1
Topics: 3647
Posts: 18912

 

Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 618
Members: 1266
Moderators: 1
Admins: 2
Most Users Ever Online: 1147
Currently Online:
Guest(s) 45
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)