Home » Discussion Forum

Discussion Forum—A Way with Words, a fun radio show and podcast about language

Discussion Forum (Archived)

Please consider registering
Guest
Forum Scope


Match



Forum Options



Min search length: 3 characters / Max search length: 84 characters
The forums are currently locked and only available for read only access
sp_TopicIcon
Shut the light
Guest
1
2013/03/12 - 11:21am

On the show I was a bit suprised to find out people think "shut the light" is an unusual expression.     I've used it all my life and no one has ever commented on it.   I notice I use it a bit differently than "turn off the light".   I would say "shut the light" when the result would be darkness, not meaning to turn off a desk lamp, for example.     This is analogous to shut (off) the TV or the car, or the fan or the burner or the faucet.   Maybe these are also unusual to people?

Guest
2
2013/03/12 - 3:51pm
All of those examples are unfamiliar to me, though I can see 'shut' makes sense where you control all the lights in a large office complex from a central control box.
————————————--
Just remember this by Bob Dylan-
Shut the light, shut the shade
You don't have to be afraid
I'll be your baby tonight
Though clearly it's also required there for aesthetic.
EmmettRedd
859 Posts
(Offline)
Guest
4
2013/03/13 - 10:02am

I use "turn off" most. Now that's an anachronistic verb phrase! I would use "shut off" or "kill" (in some contexts) without thinking twice. I have heard "shut the light." I might have used it rarely, in a distracted moment.

For me, there are slightly different contexts for each of the phrases, while all are possible in any context. I would more likely use "turn off" when speaking of a single fixture or switch. "Turn off the light on the table." For multiple lights, I would more likely use "shut off." Shut off the living-room lights. To emphasize complete darkness only might I use "kill." "Kill the lights in the basement."

Guest
5
2013/03/13 - 3:13pm

This got me thinking about the use of "turn" to describe controlling a light. Especially since the mechanical action is better described as "flip" or "toggle." And these days, with the new touch-sensitive controllers, perhaps "touch" or "tap" is a better description. And no ... I don't want to include "clap."

Ngrams shows this interesting result for the phrase "turn off the light."

Makes me wonder if the use of "turn" dates to the time when kerosene and gas lamps started replacing candles for nighttime illumination. With those devices, one would literally "turn" a control to retract the wick or shut off the flow of gas. Of course, you couldn't "turn" the light on without the assistance of a flame.

Also, just to stay on topic, I never use the phrase "shut the light." Don't think I've ever even heard it before. Grew up in the Midwest, now living in Arizona.

 

Guest
6
2013/03/13 - 5:39pm

I was just playing with the ngram viewer and found that "extinguish the light" was very popular in the 19th century. I don't know what that means.

EmmettRedd
859 Posts
(Offline)
7
2013/03/13 - 6:26pm

Heimhenge said

Of course, you couldn't "turn" the light on without the assistance of a flame.
 

But, with once lit with a flame, you could "turn up the light".

Guest
8
2013/03/14 - 7:12am

Heimhenge said

This got me thinking about the use of "turn" to describe controlling a light.

 

That's why I said it was anachronistic. It appears that the use of turn for electricity dates back to 1800s. I feel confident that it relates to some turning motion at root, be it a wick key, a gas key, or a turning electrical switch.

Guest
9
2013/03/14 - 3:30pm

More likely wick or gas keys, which were rotary. Turns out the first real electrical light switches were push-button affairs. I did not know that. So it seems the phrase "turn off the light" must indeed predate electrical lights.

Guest
10
2013/03/14 - 6:29pm

Today, in one of my company's conference rooms, there was a printed sign: Please shut projector. Thank you.

Somebody had added the handwritten word "off" after "projector."

[edit: added the following]
Maybe it's just me, but I have several lamps that have rotary switches in the bulb socket, and some that have rotary switches on the cord. Now those are lights you can really turn on! In addition, there is the light in the refrigerator or in the car that comes on when you open the door. Now there's a light you can shut!

I neglected to mention that I do sometimes say "flip the light on (or off)." Does anyone else use this one? When I flip a light off, it is not nearly as rude as when I, perhaps commuting to work, flip a person off.

Ron Draney
721 Posts
(Offline)
11
2013/03/15 - 1:06pm

Back in my first job out of college, I had to write a set of instructions for people of various backgrounds to use a computer program. At the end of a sequence of characters, the impulse would have been to say "Hit the ENTER key", since that's the verb most of us used in conversation.

Then someone pointed out that while "hit" was fine for secretaries, clerks and accountants, it might encourage the miners and smelter workers to be a little too rough with the keyboard. A long discussion ensued about just how you should describe the action: "push" the key? "activate" it?

One suggestion was "depress the ENTER key". My response to this was to lean in very close to the keyboard and whisper softly "Nobody likes you!"

Guest
12
2013/03/15 - 5:04pm

Ron Draney said:   One suggestion was "depress the ENTER key". My response to this was to lean in very close to the keyboard and whisper softly "Nobody likes you!"

Hilarious! I once had to write an instruction manual for a robotics kit. Knowing that most of the users would be geeks gave me an advantage in language choices, but I opted to make it as clear as possible by using graphic "icons" to represent key stroke sequences. So when I needed to include an "enter" stroke, I literally used a small rectangle with the word ENTER in caps, just as it's seen on the keyboard.

Still, I ran into problems when it came to escape sequences or other multiple key combinations. Had to resort to a "definitions" page up front that explained things like "when the keys are to be pressed simultaneously, the key icons will be separated by a plus sign" and other such conventions. The word I chose for using   a key was simply "press." I don't think anyone was confused by my manual. Images work better than words in such applications. Take a look at the owners manual for any modern graphing calculator. They all use key icons for key stroke sequences.

Guest
13
2013/03/15 - 11:24pm

 "Nobody likes you!"

My wife says, "Turn on that lamp." I caress the lampshade and murmur to it, "I love you."

Guest
14
2013/03/16 - 3:34am

It seems weird that the same prefixes lend opposite meanings :

de.press / de.compress  
dis.tend / dis.arm
im.pose / im.pair
in.sure / in.secure
ir.radiate / ir.regular  
a.light / a.morphous  
 
But that's only because they are different things that only look identical.
Guest
15
2013/03/24 - 10:45am

During the explanation about this Grant, Martha and the guest mused that turn of the light didn't make any sense.

It is my opinion having worked on old residential electrical systems it likely comes from oil lamps, Gas Lighting and from early days of electrical lighting.

The later oil lamps using a wick had a mechanism which you turned to raise and lower the wick.

 

Gas lamps had a valve you would turn

Early electric light switches where rotary
http://www.electrical-contractor.net/mt/SWS.JPG

As you can clearly see there is a long long history of turning something to operate a lighting device.

Guest
16
2013/03/24 - 3:56pm

Wow, Mattmaxon, nice visual documentation in support of "turn" as a means for controlling light. Thank you for that research. And welcome to the forum.

 

Guest
17
2013/03/25 - 6:31am

Mattmaxon said

As you can clearly see there is a long long history of turning something to operate a lighting device.

Welcome. And thank you for vindicating my memory and assertion above that I have seen turning electrical switches in old homes.

AnMa
67 Posts
(Offline)
18
2013/05/10 - 6:36am

For some data on regionalisms, in Indian English, these forms are the most common:

"On the light"/"Open the light"

"Off the light"/"Close the light"

(Note that "on" and "off" are being used as verbs in imperative form.)

When I've been in India, I heard these much more often than the usual American-style forms:

"Turn on the light"

"Turn off the light"/"Shut off the light."

EmmettRedd
859 Posts
(Offline)
19
2013/08/28 - 7:59am

The other night I saw an episode of The Neighbors where Marty Weaver (the human father) used the topic phrase, "Shut the lights."

EmmettRedd
859 Posts
(Offline)
20
2013/08/28 - 8:41am

Heimhenge said

This got me thinking about the use of "turn" to describe controlling a light. Especially since the mechanical action is better described as "flip" or "toggle." And these days, with the new touch-sensitive controllers, perhaps "touch" or "tap" is a better description. And no ... I don't want to include "clap."
 

And, re-reading the thread after my last post got me to thinking about the mental concepts/constructs that a person has behind various words. In the first three cases mentioned above, the mechanical motion of the operating mechanism is rotation. However, there may be a distinction between those words depending on the axis of rotation or the shape of the mechanism.

It seems that when the axis of rotation passes through me, the word "turn" is used. But, when the axis of rotation is in the horizontal or vertical directions--not passing through me--the word is "flip" ("toggle" is problematic). OR, does it matter whether it is easier to operate the mechanical mechanism with one finger ("flip") or thumb and finger ("turn")? I do not think it is the amount of rotation because some old radio and television switches turned them on or off with less rotation than many light switches have which might be flipped.

What are your thoughts about rotation of mechanisms?

Emmett

Forum Timezone: America/Los_Angeles
Show Stats
Administrators:
Martha Barnette
Grant Barrett
Moderators:
Grant Barrett
Top Posters:
Newest Members:
Eileen Kosnik
Forum Stats:
Groups: 1
Forums: 1
Topics: 3647
Posts: 18912

 

Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 618
Members: 1267
Moderators: 1
Admins: 2
Most Users Ever Online: 1147
Currently Online:
Guest(s) 19
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)